Cards listed on April 16
| Set | # | Card Title | Pro Team | College | Grade | Price | Notes | Date Added |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1935 National Chicle | 21 | Cliff Montgomery | Brooklyn Dodgers | Columbia | PSA 1.5 | 142.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1950 Bowman | 1 | Doak Walker | Detroit Lions | SMU | PSA 6 mk | 261.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1950 Bowman | 6 | Lou Groza | Cleveland Browns | Ohio State | PSA 5 | 191.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1950 Bowman | 8 | Mac Speedie | Cleveland Browns | Utah | PSA 3 | 153.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1950 Bowman | 52 | Elroy Hirsch | Los Angeles Rams | Wisconsin, Michigan | PSA 5 | 304.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1950 Bowman | 52 | Elroy Hirsch | Los Angeles Rams | Wisconsin, Michigan | PSA 4 | 183.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1950 Bowman | 100 | Sammy Baugh | Washington Redskins | TCU | PSA 4 | 238.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1950 Bowman | 100 | Sammy Baugh | Washington Redskins | TCU | PSA 3 | 158.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1951 Bowman | 51 | Ed Sprinkle | Chicago Bears | Hardin-Simmons, Navy | PSA 4 | 294.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1951 Bowman | 51 | Ed Sprinkle | Chicago Bears | Hardin-Simmons, Navy | PSA 3.5 | 261.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1951 Bowman | 62 | Lou Creekmur | Detroit Lions | William and Mary | PSA 7.5 | 435.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1951 Topps Magic | 48 | George Young | Bucknell | PSA 3 | 131.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 | |
| 1951 Topps Magic | 48 | George Young | Bucknell | PSA 3.5 | 128.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 | |
| 1951 Topps Magic | 48 | George Young | Bucknell | PSA 2 | 94.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 | |
| 1952 Bowman Large | 29 | Hugh McElhenny | San Francisco 49ers | Washington | PSA 3 | 198.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1952 Bowman Large | 130 | Dom Moselle | Green Bay Packers | Wisconsin - Superior | PSA 8 | 1139.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1952 Bowman Large | 136 | Bert Rechichar | Cleveland Browns | Tennessee | PSA 4.5 | 131.00 | short print | Apr 16 |
| 1952 Parkhurst | 50 | Jim Mitchener | Montreal Alouettes | McGill | PSA 6 | 156.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1955 Bowman | 18 | Max Boydston | Chicago Cardinals | Oklahoma | SGC 88 | 31.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1955 Bowman | 34 | Bob Haner | Washington Redskins | Villanova | SGC 88 | 26.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1955 Bowman | 39 | Dick Flanagan | Pittsburgh Steelers | Ohio State | SGC 88 | 24.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1955 Bowman | 117 | William Brown | Green Bay Packers | Arkansas | PSA 7 | 57.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1955 Bowman | 137 | Kyle Rote | New York Giants | SMU | PSA 7.5 | 575.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1955 Topps All-American | 37 | Jim Thorpe | Carlisle | PSA 1 | 299.00 | Apr 16 | ||
| 1955 Topps All-American | 56 | Ernie Nevers | Stanford | PSA 6 | 139.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 | |
| 1955 Topps All-American | 84 | Ace Parker | Duke | PSA 6 | 112.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 | |
| 1957 Topps | 85 | Dick Lane | Chicago Cardinals | Scottsbluff Junior College | PSA 5 | 106.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1958 Topps | 22 | John Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Louisville | PSA 4 | 118.00 | error card | Apr 16 |
| 1958 Topps | 66 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 7 oc | 200.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1958 Topps | 66 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 5 | 148.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1959 Topps | 1 | John Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Louisville | poor | 28.00 | pin hole, otherwise vg | Apr 16 |
| 1959 Topps | 23 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 6 | 174.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1959 Topps | 132 | Jim Parker | Baltimore Colts | Ohio State | PSA 8 | 263.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1960 Bell Brand Rams | 10 | Ollie Matson | Los Angeles Rams | San Francisco | PSA 8 | 295.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1960 Topps | 6 | George Preas | Baltimore Colts | Virginia Tech | PSA 8 | 96.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1960 Topps | 99 | Dean Derby | Pittsburgh Steelers | Washington | SGC 92 | 41.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1960 Topps CFL | 22 | Jim Bakhtiar | Calgary Stampeders | Virginia | PSA 8 | 29.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1960 Topps CFL | 67 | Dave Thelen | Ottawa Rough Riders | Miami Ohio | PSA 8 | 30.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1961 Topps | 92 | Jim Patton | New York Giants | Mississippi | PSA 9 | 258.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1962 Topps | 63 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 6 | 263.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1962 Topps | 63 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 5 | 161.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1962 Topps | 86 | Les Richter | Los Angeles Rams | California | PSA 7 | 44.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1963 Topps | 44 | Deacon Jones | Los Angeles Rams | Mississippi Valley State, South Carolina State | vg-ex mk | 26.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1964 Topps | 41 | John Tracey | Buffalo Bills | Texas A and M | PSA 7 | 83.00 | rookie card, short print | Apr 16 |
| 1964 Topps | 42 | Sid Youngelman | Buffalo Bills | Alabama | PSA 7 | 61.00 | short print | Apr 16 |
| 1964 Topps | 73 | Don Floyd | Houston Oilers | TCU | PSA 8 | 89.00 | short print | Apr 16 |
| 1965 Topps | 150 | Harry Schuh | Oakland Raiders | Memphis | PSA 7 | 63.00 | rookie card | Apr 16 |
| 1966 Philadelphia | 118 | New York Giants Team | New York Giants | PSA 7 | 13.00 | double print | Apr 16 | |
| 1967 Philadelphia | 24 | Colts Logo | Baltimore Colts | PSA 7 | 97.00 | Apr 16 | ||
| 1967 Philadelphia | 59 | Mel Renfro | Dallas Cowboys | Oregon | PSA 5 | 53.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1967 Royal Castle Dolphins | 16 | Bob Neff | Miami Dolphins | Stephen F. Austin | PSA 6 | 127.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1967 Topps | 13 | Nick Buoniconti | Boston Patriots | Notre Dame | PSA 8 | 118.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1968 KDKA Steelers | 6 | Flanker - End | PSA 7 | 35.00 | Apr 16 | |||
| Ken Hebert | Pittsburgh Steelers | Houston | ||||||
| Roy Jefferson | Pittsburgh Steelers | Utah | ||||||
| 1968 Topps | 65 | Joe Namath | poor | 20.00 | Apr 16 | |||
| Jim Harris | New York Jets | Utah State | ||||||
| Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | ||||||
| 1968 Topps | 168 | Fred Biletnikoff | Oakland Raiders | Florida State | PSA 5 | 23.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1968 Topps Stand Up | 18 | Bill Nelsen | Pittsburgh Steelers | USC | PSA 8 | 132.00 | Apr 16 | |
| 1971 Topps | 250 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | PSA 5 | 88.00 | Apr 16 | |