Cards listed on April 15
| Set | # | Card Title | Pro Team | College | Grade | Price | Notes | Date Added |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1950 Bowman | 45 | Otto Graham | Cleveland Browns | Northwestern | PSA 1 | 446.00 | rookie card | |
| 1950 Bowman | 79 | Tony Adamle | Cleveland Browns | Ohio State | SGC 88 | 163.00 | rookie card | |
| 1955 Topps All-American | 37 | Jim Thorpe | Carlisle | PSA 2 mc | 442.00 | |||
| 1959 Topps | 23 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 4 | 87.00 | ||
| 1960 Topps | 51 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 8 | 467.00 | ||
| 1960 Topps | 51 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 7 | 224.00 | ||
| 1961 Fleer | 88 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 8 | 595.00 | error card | |
| 1961 Packers Lake to Lake | 2 | Norm Masters | Green Bay Packers | Michigan State | PSA 7 | 3946.00 | short print | |
| 1961 Topps | 15 | Doug Atkins | Chicago Bears | Tennessee | PSA 8 | 50.00 | cracked case | |
| 1961 Topps | 34 | Jim Martin | Detroit Lions | Notre Dame | PSA 8 | 70.00 | ||
| 1961 Topps | 101 | Chuck Bednarik | Philadelphia Eagles | Pennsylvania | PSA 8 | 166.00 | ||
| 1961 Topps | 103 | Philadelphia Eagles Team | Philadelphia Eagles | PSA 8 | 63.00 | |||
| 1961 Topps | 153 | Bob Mischak | New York Titans | Army | PSA 8 | 37.00 | rookie card | |
| 1961 Topps | 170 | Volney Peters | San Diego Chargers | USC | PSA 8 | 32.00 | ||
| 1962 Topps | 1 | John Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Louisville | PSA 4 | 117.00 | short print | |
| 1962 Topps | 63 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | PSA 6 | 264.00 | ||
| 1963 Fleer | 31 | Ray Abruzzese | Buffalo Bills | Alabama | PSA 8 | 118.00 | rookie card, error card | |
| 1963 Fleer | 63 | Fred Williamson | Oakland Raiders | Northwestern | PSA 8 | 103.00 | ||
| 1963 Topps | 95 | Willie Wood | Green Bay Packers | USC | PSA 8 | 570.00 | rookie card | |
| 1963 Topps | 155 | Larry Wilson | St. Louis Cardinals | Utah | PSA 8 | 250.00 | rookie card | |
| 1964 Topps | 82 | Checklist | PSA 8 | 148.00 | ||||
| 1966 Philadelphia | 31 | Dick Butkus | Chicago Bears | Illinois | PSA 4 | 482.00 | rookie card | |
| 1966 Philadelphia | 58 | Bob Hayes | Dallas Cowboys | Florida A and M | PSA 6 | 247.00 | rookie card | |
| 1966 Topps | 125 | John Hadl | San Diego Chargers | Kansas | PSA 8 | 109.00 | ||
| 1966 Topps | 127 | Keith Lincoln | San Diego Chargers | Washington State | PSA 8 | 56.00 | ||
| 1967 Topps | 95 | Winston Hill | New York Jets | Texas Southern | PSA 8 | 87.00 | ||
| 1969 Topps | 100 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | PSA 7 | 352.00 | ||
| 1969 Topps | 100 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | PSA 5 | 129.00 |