Cards listed on October 9
| Set | # | Card Title | Pro Team | College | Grade | Price | Notes | Date Added |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1948 Leaf | 34 | Sammy Baugh | Washington Redskins | TCU | PSA 2 | 482.00 | rookie card, red jersey | |
| 1950 Bowman | 8 | Mac Speedie | Cleveland Browns | Utah | PSA 5 | 270.00 | rookie card | |
| 1950 Bowman | 45 | Otto Graham | Cleveland Browns | Northwestern | PSA 4 mc | 952.00 | rookie card | |
| 1954 Bowman | 58 | Art Hunter | Green Bay Packers | Notre Dame | PSA 8 | 66.00 | rookie card | |
| 1955 Bowman | 2 | Mike McCormack | Cleveland Browns | Kansas | exmt | 44.00 | rookie card | |
| 1960 Topps | 25 | Bobby Mitchell | Cleveland Browns | Illinois | PSA 8 | 72.00 | ||
| 1960 Topps | 58 | Bill Forester | Green Bay Packers | SMU | PSA 8 | 62.00 | ||
| 1960 Topps | 70 | John Baker | Los Angeles Rams | North Carolina College | PSA 8 | 54.00 | rookie card | |
| 1960 Topps | 82 | New York Giants Team | New York Giants | PSA 8 | 78.00 | |||
| 1962 Fleer | 15 | Tom Rychlec | Buffalo Bills | American International | PSA 8 | 190.00 | ||
| 1962 Topps | 38 | Eddie LeBaron | Dallas Cowboys | Pacific | exmt+ | 22.00 | ||
| 1963 Fleer | 7 | Bill Neighbors | Boston Patriots | Alabama | PSA 8 | 60.00 | rookie card | |
| 1963 Fleer | 45 | Curtis McClinton | Kansas City Chiefs | Kansas | PSA 8 | 123.00 | rookie card | |
| 1963 Topps | 96 | Ray Nitschke | Green Bay Packers | Illinois | PSA 6 | 244.00 | rookie card | |
| 1964 Topps | 35 | Ed Rutkowski | Buffalo Bills | Notre Dame | PSA 8 | 37.00 | rookie card | |
| 1964 Topps | 105 | Johnny Robinson | Kansas City Chiefs | LSU | ex | 56.00 | short print | |
| 1964 Topps | 139 | Tom Flores | Oakland Raiders | Pacific | PSA 8 | 1658.00 | short print | |
| 1964 Topps | 146 | Alan Miller | Oakland Raiders | Boston College | PSA 8 | 97.00 | short print | |
| 1964 Topps | 156 | George Blair | San Diego Chargers | Mississippi | PSA 8 | 28.00 | rookie card | |
| 1965 Topps | 137 | Ben Davidson | Oakland Raiders | Washington | PSA 8 | 427.00 | rookie card | |
| 1966 Philadelphia | 38 | Gale Sayers | Chicago Bears | Kansas | PSA 5 | 459.00 | rookie card, double print | |
| 1966 Philadelphia | 50 | Dick Schafrath | Cleveland Browns | Ohio State | PSA 8 | 92.00 | ||
| 1966 Philadelphia | 135 | Timmy Brown | Philadelphia Eagles | Ball State | PSA 8 | 71.00 | ||
| 1966 Topps | 36 | Jerry Hopkins | Denver Broncos | Texas A and M | PSA 8 | 31.00 | ||
| 1966 Topps | 37 | Ray Jacobs | Denver Broncos | Howard Payne | PSA 8 | 76.00 | ||
| 1966 Topps | 64 | Bobby Bell | Kansas City Chiefs | Minnesota | PSA 8 | 65.00 | ||
| 1966 Topps | 82 | Dave Kocourek | Miami Dolphins | Wisconsin | PSA 8 | 313.00 | ||
| 1966 Topps | 86 | Willie West | Miami Dolphins | Oregon | PSA 8 | 50.00 | rookie card | |
| 1966 Topps | 88 | Eddie Wilson | Miami Dolphins | Arizona | PSA 8 | 188.00 | rookie card | |
| 1966 Topps | 93 | Dee Mackey | New York Jets | Texas A and M - Commerce | PSA 8 | 117.00 | ||
| 1966 Topps | 108 | Ben Davidson | Oakland Raiders | Washington | PSA 8 | 137.00 | ||
| 1967 Philadelphia | 143 | Jim Skaggs | Philadelphia Eagles | Washington | PSA 8 | 57.00 | rookie card | |
| 1967 Philadelphia | 193 | Browns Play | PSA 8 | 51.00 | double print | |||
| Gene Hickerson | Cleveland Browns | Mississippi | ||||||
| Jerry Hillebrand | New York Giants | Colorado | ||||||
| Leroy Kelly | Cleveland Browns | Morgan State | ||||||
| 1968 Topps | 58 | Gary Ballman | Philadelphia Eagles | Michigan State | PSA 8 | 68.00 | ||
| 1968 Topps | 107 | Fred Cox | Minnesota Vikings | Pittsburgh | PSA 8 | 60.00 | ||
| 1968 Topps | 142 | George Blanda | Oakland Raiders | Kentucky | PSA 8 | 85.00 | ||
| 1969 Topps | 100 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | PSA 6 | 193.00 | ||
| 1969 Topps 4-in-1 | 30 | Leroy Kelly, Ed Meador, Ray Ogden, Bart Starr | exmt | 21.00 | ||||
| Leroy Kelly | Cleveland Browns | Morgan State | ||||||
| Ed Meador | Los Angeles Rams | Arkansas Tech | ||||||
| Ray Ogden | Atlanta Falcons | Alabama | ||||||
| Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | ||||||
| 1970 Topps Super Glossy | 29 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | PSA 8 | 207.00 | ||
| 1972 Topps | 200 | Roger Staubach | Dallas Cowboys | New Mexico Military Institute, Navy | PSA 5 | 223.00 | rookie card | |
| 1974 Topps | 150 | John Unitas | San Diego Chargers | Louisville | nm | 27.00 | ||
| 1976 Topps | 148 | Walter Payton | Chicago Bears | Jackson State | PSA 1 | 231.00 | rookie card | |
| 1978 Topps | 287 | Joe Klecko | New York Jets | Temple | nm | 17.00 | rookie card | |