Cards listed on April 10
| Set | # | Card Title | Pro Team | College | Grade | Price | Notes | Date Added |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1948 Leaf | 45 | Jim White | New York Giants | Notre Dame | exmt | 162.00 | rookie card | |
| 1952 Bowman Large | 33 | Fred Cone | Green Bay Packers | Clemson | vg+ | 19.00 | rookie card | |
| 1957 Topps | 85 | Dick Lane | Chicago Cardinals | Scottsbluff Junior College | good | 34.00 | rookie card | |
| 1959 Topps | 23 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | vg | 57.00 | ||
| 1960 Fleer | 84 | Jim Woodard | Oakland Raiders | Lamar | ex | 32.00 | rookie card | |
| 1961 Fleer | 88 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | ex | 71.00 | error card | |
| 1962 Topps | 1 | John Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Louisville | vg-ex+ | 83.00 | short print | |
| 1962 Topps | 36 | Ernie Davis | Cleveland Browns | Syracuse | ex | 187.00 | rookie card, short print | |
| 1962 Topps | 63 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | exmt+ oc | 62.00 | ||
| 1963 Fleer | 10 | Nick Buoniconti | Boston Patriots | Notre Dame | ex+ | 198.00 | rookie card | |
| 1963 Topps | 1 | John Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Louisville | ex | 50.00 | ||
| 1963 Topps | 123 | John Henry Johnson | Pittsburgh Steelers | Arizona State, St. Mary's | exmt+ | 53.00 | short print | |
| 1967 Milton Bradley | 98 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | vg-ex | 102.00 | ||
| 1967 Philadelphia | 59 | Mel Renfro | Dallas Cowboys | Oregon | ex | 30.00 | ||
| 1968 Topps | 1 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | exmt | 75.00 | ||
| 1968 Topps Stand Up | 17 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | exmt | 76.00 | ||
| 1970 Kelloggs | 10 | Dick Butkus | Chicago Bears | Illinois | nmmt+ | 38.00 | ||
| 1970 Topps | 43 | Elvin Bethea | Houston Oilers | North Carolina A and T | exmt | 13.00 | rookie card | |
| 1970 Topps Super Glossy | 2 | John Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Louisville | nm-mt | 89.00 | ||
| 1970 Topps Super Glossy | 9 | Bart Starr | Green Bay Packers | Alabama | nm | 60.00 | ||
| 1970 Topps Super Glossy | 15 | Fran Tarkenton | New York Giants | Georgia | nm | 25.00 | ||
| 1970 Topps Super Glossy | 22 | O.J. Simpson | Buffalo Bills | USC, City College of San Francisco | nm+ | 92.00 | ||
| 1970 Topps Super Glossy | 29 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | exmt+ | 37.00 | ||
| 1971 Topps | 245 | Joe Greene | Pittsburgh Steelers | North Texas | vgex | 76.00 | rookie card | |
| 1972 Topps | 200 | Roger Staubach | Dallas Cowboys | New Mexico Military Institute, Navy | vg mc | 57.00 | rookie card | |
| 1973 Topps | 400 | Joe Namath | New York Jets | Alabama | ex | 25.00 | ||
| 1973 Topps | 475 | Roger Staubach | Dallas Cowboys | New Mexico Military Institute, Navy | ex | 24.00 | ||
| 1973 Topps | 487 | Ken Stabler | Oakland Raiders | Alabama | vg | 30.00 | rookie card |