Baltimore Colts football cards

Click on the card title to see a picture of the card for sale.

Date Listed Set Card # Card Title Pro Team College Grade Price Notes
1950 Bowman 112 Billy Stone Baltimore Colts Bradley exmt 19.00rookie card
1950 Bowman 112 Billy Stone Baltimore Colts Bradley PSA 6 19.00rookie card
1953 Bowman 19 George Taliaferro Baltimore Colts Indiana BVG 7.5 59.00
1954 Bowman 14 Fred Enke Baltimore Colts Arizona PSA 9 429.00
1954 Bowman 14 Fred Enke Baltimore Colts Arizona exmt 6.00
1954 Bowman 38 Buddy Young Baltimore Colts Illinois PSA 9 259.00
1954 Bowman 38 Buddy Young Baltimore Colts Illinois nm 12.00
1954 Bowman 62 Bill Lange Baltimore Colts Dayton PSA 8.5 75.00
1954 Bowman 72 Tom Keane Baltimore Colts West Virginia SGC 96 249.00rookie card, short print
1955 Bowman 8 Alan Ameche Baltimore Colts Wisconsin PSA 8.5 395.00rookie card, error card
1955 Bowman 8 Alan Ameche Baltimore Colts Wisconsin good 4.00rookie card, error card
1955 Bowman 20 Bert Rechichar Baltimore Colts Tennessee PSA 8 39.00
1955 Bowman 65 Buddy Young Baltimore Colts Illinois PSA 8.5 159.00
1955 Bowman 65 Buddy Young Baltimore Colts Illinois PSA 8 89.00
1955 Bowman 97 George Taliaferro Baltimore Colts Indiana PSA 8 195.00
1955 Bowman 97 George Taliaferro Baltimore Colts Indiana PSA 8 oc 35.00
1955 Bowman 103 Carl Taseff Baltimore Colts John Carroll nm 18.00rookie card
1955 Bowman 107 Art Spinney Baltimore Colts Boston College PSA 8 65.00
1955 Bowman 107 Art Spinney Baltimore Colts Boston College nm 14.00
1955 Bowman 114 Doug Eggers Baltimore Colts South Dakota State SGC 84 19.00
1955 Bowman 114 Doug Eggers Baltimore Colts South Dakota State exmt 7.00
1955 Bowman 114 Doug Eggers Baltimore Colts South Dakota State PSA 4 5.00
1955 Bowman 118 Royce Womble Baltimore Colts North Texas PSA 8 55.00rookie card
1955 Bowman 118 Royce Womble Baltimore Colts North Texas PSA 5 5.00rookie card
1955 Bowman 147 Zollie Toth Baltimore Colts LSU PSA 8 75.00
1956 Topps 24 Joe Campanella Baltimore Colts Ohio State exmt 7.00
1956 Topps 36 Art Donovan Baltimore Colts Boston College, Notre Dame SGC 84 25.00
1956 Topps 72 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Notre Dame nm 15.00rookie card
1956 Topps 72 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Notre Dame PSA 6 15.00rookie card
1956 Topps 84 Bert Rechichar Baltimore Colts Tennessee nm oc 5.00
1956 Topps 96 Buddy Young Baltimore Colts Illinois nm oc 5.00
1956 Topps 108 George Shaw Baltimore Colts Oregon nm oc 5.00rookie card
1956 Topps 120 Billy Vessels Baltimore Colts Oklahoma PSA 6 22.00rookie card
1957 Topps 5 Gino Marchetti Baltimore Colts San Francisco ex 5.00
1957 Topps 41 Bert Rechichar Baltimore Colts Tennessee nm+ 9.00
Jul 24 1957 Topps 53 Alan Ameche Baltimore Colts Wisconsin ex+ 5.00
1957 Topps 65 Art Donovan Baltimore Colts Boston College, Notre Dame SGC 88 59.00
1957 Topps 65 Art Donovan Baltimore Colts Boston College, Notre Dame nm 29.00
1957 Topps 77 Carl Taseff Baltimore Colts John Carroll SGC 88 25.00
1957 Topps 77 Carl Taseff Baltimore Colts John Carroll PSA 8 oc 12.00
1957 Topps 77 Carl Taseff Baltimore Colts John Carroll nm 7.00
1957 Topps 86 Royce Womble Baltimore Colts North Texas nm 8.00
1957 Topps 103 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Notre Dame nm 19.00
1957 Topps 115 George Shaw Baltimore Colts Oregon exmt 12.00
1957 Topps 128 Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts Penn State ex 25.00corner crease
1957 Topps 138 John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville PSA 3 195.00rookie card
Jul 24 1958 Topps 12 Alan Ameche Baltimore Colts Wisconsin exmt+ 9.00
1958 Topps 14 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Notre Dame PSA 8 85.00
1958 Topps 14 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Notre Dame vg-ex 1.00
1958 Topps 74 Bert Rechichar Baltimore Colts Tennessee vg-ex 1.00light crease on back
1958 Topps 98 Milt Davis Baltimore Colts Los Angeles City, UCLA SGC 84 15.00rookie card
1958 Topps 98 Milt Davis Baltimore Colts Los Angeles City, UCLA nm 9.00rookie card
1958 Topps 106 Art Donovan Baltimore Colts Boston College, Notre Dame nm 12.00
1958 Topps 110 Baltimore Colts Team Baltimore Colts ex+ 5.00
1958 Topps 117 L.G. Dupre Baltimore Colts Baylor exmt 5.00
1959 Topps 17 Baltimore Colts Team Baltimore Colts vg 2.00
1959 Topps 30 Alan Ameche Baltimore Colts Wisconsin exmt 9.00
1959 Topps 36 Gene Lipscomb Baltimore Colts exmt 9.00rookie card
1959 Topps 43 Steve Myhra Baltimore Colts North Dakota exmt 5.00rookie card
1959 Topps 55 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU nm oc 5.00
1959 Topps 78 Buzz Nutter Baltimore Colts VPI nm 7.00rookie card
1959 Topps 86 Art Donovan Baltimore Colts Boston College, Notre Dame vg 2.00
1959 Topps 89 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Notre Dame nm oc 3.00
1959 Topps 100 Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts Penn State nm oc 9.00
1959 Topps 109 Gino Marchetti Baltimore Colts San Francisco ex 3.00
1959 Topps 132 Jim Parker Baltimore Colts Ohio State vg-ex 9.00rookie card
1959 Topps 149 Leo Sanford Baltimore Colts Louisiana Tech ex 2.00
1959 Topps 163 L.G. Dupre Baltimore Colts Baylor exmt+ 4.00
1959 Topps 171 Art Spinney Baltimore Colts Boston College PSA 7 9.00
1959 Topps 171 Art Spinney Baltimore Colts Boston College nm 5.00
1960 Topps 4 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU exmt 9.00
1960 Topps 5 Jim Parker Baltimore Colts Ohio State PSA 9 195.00
1960 Topps 5 Jim Parker Baltimore Colts Ohio State exmt 5.00
1960 Topps 7 Art Spinney Baltimore Colts Boston College PSA 5 3.00
1960 Topps 9 John Sample Baltimore Colts Maryland Eastern Shore exmt 2.00rookie card
1960 Topps 9 John Sample Baltimore Colts Maryland Eastern Shore PSA 5 2.00rookie card
1960 Topps 10 Gene Lipscomb Baltimore Colts nm 7.00
1961 Fleer 33 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU PSA 6.5 12.00
1961 Fleer 34 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Notre Dame PSA 8 25.00
1961 Fleer 38 Gene Lipscomb Baltimore Colts nm 12.00
1961 Topps 1 John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville PSA 6 69.00
1961 Topps 4 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU exmt 9.00
1961 Topps 7 Gino Marchetti Baltimore Colts San Francisco nm+ 12.00
1961 Topps 9 Baltimore Colts Team Baltimore Colts exmt 5.00
1962 Topps 1 John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville PSA 7 449.00short print
1962 Topps 5 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU PSA 7 55.00
1962 Topps 12 Baltimore Colts Team Baltimore Colts PSA 7 49.00short print
1963 Topps 2 Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts Penn State ex+ 5.00
1963 Topps 3 Jimmy Orr Baltimore Colts Georgia exmt 5.00
1963 Topps 4 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU nm 15.00
1963 Topps 6 Alex Sandusky Baltimore Colts Clarion Teachers College PSA 8 29.00
1963 Topps 6 Alex Sandusky Baltimore Colts Clarion Teachers College nm+ oc 3.00
1963 Topps 7 Dick Szymanski Baltimore Colts Notre Dame PSA 8 35.00rookie card
1963 Topps 9 Billy Ray Smith Baltimore Colts Arkansas PSA 8 65.00rookie card
1963 Topps 10 Bill Pellington Baltimore Colts Rutgers PSA 8 oc 9.00
1963 Topps 10 Bill Pellington Baltimore Colts Rutgers nm oc 3.00
1964 Philadelphia 1 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU ex 9.00
1964 Philadelphia 2 Tom Gilburg Baltimore Colts Syracuse nm oc 2.00
1964 Philadelphia 5 Jim Martin Baltimore Colts Notre Dame SGC 92 25.00
1964 Philadelphia 5 Jim Martin Baltimore Colts Notre Dame nm+ 6.00
1964 Philadelphia 8 Jim Parker Baltimore Colts Ohio State nm 9.00
1964 Philadelphia 9 Bill Pellington Baltimore Colts Rutgers SGC 92 25.00
1964 Philadelphia 10 Alex Sandusky Baltimore Colts Clarion Teachers College PSA 9 95.00
1964 Philadelphia 10 Alex Sandusky Baltimore Colts Clarion Teachers College nm 5.00
1964 Philadelphia 12 John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville vg mc 9.00miscut
1964 Philadelphia 14 Colts Play of the Year exmt 9.00
Don Shula Baltimore Colts John Carroll
1965 Philadelphia 5 Jerry Logan Baltimore Colts West Texas State SGC 92 19.00rookie card, double print
1965 Philadelphia 5 Jerry Logan Baltimore Colts West Texas State nm 4.00rookie card, double print
1965 Philadelphia 6 Tony Lorick Baltimore Colts Arizona State nm 3.00rookie card, double print
1965 Philadelphia 7 Lou Michaels Baltimore Colts Kentucky PSA 9 75.00
1965 Philadelphia 8 Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts Penn State exmt 6.00
1965 Philadelphia 9 Jimmy Orr Baltimore Colts Georgia nm 4.00double print
1965 Philadelphia 10 Jim Parker Baltimore Colts Ohio State PSA 7 15.00
1965 Philadelphia 11 Dick Szymanski Baltimore Colts Notre Dame nm 4.00
1965 Philadelphia 12 John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville exmt 25.00
1965 Philadelphia 14 Colts Play of the Year nm+ oc 12.00
Don Shula Baltimore Colts John Carroll
1966 Philadelphia 15 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU nm 12.00double print
1966 Philadelphia 17 Jerry Logan Baltimore Colts West Texas State nm 5.00double print
1966 Philadelphia 18 John Mackey Baltimore Colts Syracuse ex+ 6.00double print
1966 Philadelphia 20 Lou Michaels Baltimore Colts Kentucky ex+ 2.00
1966 Philadelphia 21 Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts Penn State ex 4.00
1966 Philadelphia 23 Jim Parker Baltimore Colts Ohio State exmt 9.00
1967 Philadelphia 14 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts SMU exmt 7.00error card
1967 Philadelphia 15 Bob Boyd Baltimore Colts Oklahoma PSA 9 49.00double print
1967 Philadelphia 15 Bob Boyd Baltimore Colts Oklahoma SGC 92 25.00double print
1967 Philadelphia 15 Bob Boyd Baltimore Colts Oklahoma exmt 2.00double print
1967 Philadelphia 17 Alvin Haymond Baltimore Colts Southern SGC 96 49.00rookie card, double print
Aug 6 1967 Philadelphia 17 Alvin Haymond Baltimore Colts Southern PSA 8 15.00rookie card, double print
1967 Philadelphia 17 Alvin Haymond Baltimore Colts Southern exmt 2.00rookie card, double print
1967 Philadelphia 18 Tony Lorick Baltimore Colts Arizona State PSA 8 15.00double print
1967 Philadelphia 18 Tony Lorick Baltimore Colts Arizona State nm 5.00double print
1967 Philadelphia 19 Lenny Lyles Baltimore Colts Louisville ex 3.00rookie card
1967 Philadelphia 20 John Mackey Baltimore Colts Syracuse ex 5.00wax on back
1967 Philadelphia 22 Lou Michaels Baltimore Colts Kentucky PSA 7 25.00
1968 Topps 152 Willie Richardson Baltimore Colts Jackson State nm 5.00rookie card
1968 Topps 204 Tony Lorick Baltimore Colts Arizona State nm 5.00
1968 Topps 213 Lenny Lyles Baltimore Colts Louisville exmt 2.00
1969 Topps 5 Willie Richardson Baltimore Colts Jackson State nm 4.00
1969 Topps 25 John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville PSA 9 795.00
1969 Topps 72 Lenny Lyles Baltimore Colts Louisville nm+ 5.00
1969 Topps 94 Jerry Hill Baltimore Colts Wyoming exmt 2.00rookie card
1969 Topps 116 Lou Michaels Baltimore Colts Kentucky nm+ 5.00
1969 Topps 185 Billy Ray Smith Baltimore Colts Arkansas exmt 2.50
1969 Topps 207 John Mackey Baltimore Colts Syracuse PSA 6 6.00
1969 Topps 4-in-1 6 Gary Ballman, Jerry Hill, Boyd Dowler, Roy Jefferson PSA 10 795.00
Gary Ballman Philadelphia Eagles Michigan State
Jerry Hill Baltimore Colts Wyoming
Boyd Dowler Green Bay Packers Colorado
Roy Jefferson Pittsburgh Steelers Utah
1969 Topps 4-in-1 17 Pete Gogolak, Ron Bull, Willie Richardson, Chuck LaTourette nm+ 8.00
Pete Gogolak New York Giants Cornell
Ron Bull Chicago Bears Baylor
Willie Richardson Baltimore Colts Jackson State
Chuck LaTourette St. Louis Cardinals Rice
1969 Topps 4-in-1 34 Jim Lindsey, Ray Nitschke, Bob Vogel, Rickie Harris PSA 8 45.00
Jim Lindsey Minnesota Vikings Arkansas
Ray Nitschke Green Bay Packers Illinois
Bob Vogel Baltimore Colts Ohio State
Rickie Harris Washington Redskins Arizona
1969 Topps 4-in-1 35 Billy Lothridge, Herb Adderley, John Mackey, Charlie Gogolak PSA 9 249.00
Billy Lothridge Atlanta Falcons Georgia Tech
Herb Adderley Green Bay Packers Michigan State
John Mackey Baltimore Colts Syracuse
Charlie Gogolak Washington Redskins Princeton
1969 Topps 4-in-1 35 Billy Lothridge, Herb Adderley, John Mackey, Charlie Gogolak nm 12.00
Billy Lothridge Atlanta Falcons Georgia Tech
Herb Adderley Green Bay Packers Michigan State
John Mackey Baltimore Colts Syracuse
Charlie Gogolak Washington Redskins Princeton
1969 Topps 4-in-1 41 Bill Nelsen, Bill Munson, Mike Curtis, Nate Ramsey exmt 3.00
Bill Nelsen Cleveland Browns USC
Bill Munson Detroit Lions Utah State
Mike Curtis Baltimore Colts Duke
Nate Ramsey Philadelphia Eagles Indiana
1969 Topps 4-in-1 45 Nick Rassas, Tom Matte, Bobby Mitchell, Lance Rentzel nm 9.00
Nick Rassas Atlanta Falcons Notre Dame
Tom Matte Baltimore Colts Ohio State
Bobby Mitchell Washington Redskins Illinois
Lance Rentzel Dallas Cowboys Oklahoma
1969 Topps 4-in-1 57 Clendon Thomas, Don McCall, Lonnie Warwick, Earl Morrall nm+ 8.00
Clendon Thomas Pittsburgh Steelers Oklahoma
Don McCall New Orleans Saints Los Angeles City, USC
Lonnie Warwick Minnesota Vikings Tennessee Tech
Earl Morrall Baltimore Colts Michigan State
1969 Topps 4-in-1 59 John Unitas, Les Josephson, Mel Renfro, Fred Cox PSA 8 49.00
John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville
Les Josephson Los Angeles Rams Augustana
Mel Renfro Dallas Cowboys Oregon
Fred Cox Minnesota Vikings Pittsburgh
1969 Topps 4-in-1 63 Larry Wilson, Lou Michaels, Earl Gros, Billy Gambrell PSA 9 249.00
Larry Wilson St. Louis Cardinals Utah
Lou Michaels Baltimore Colts Kentucky
Earl Gros Pittsburgh Steelers LSU
Billy Gambrell Detroit Lions South Carolina
1970 Kelloggs 3 Tom Matte Baltimore Colts Ohio State nm 4.00
1970 Kelloggs 46 Bubba Smith Baltimore Colts Michigan State nm 5.00
1970 Topps 62 John Mackey Baltimore Colts Syracuse nm 5.00
1970 Topps Super Glossy 2 John Unitas Baltimore Colts Louisville nm 35.00
1970 Topps Super Glossy 3 Tom Matte Baltimore Colts Ohio State nm 6.00
1971 Topps 80 Mike Curtis Baltimore Colts Duke nm 3.00
1971 Topps Game 4 Mike Curtis Baltimore Colts Duke nm+ 5.00
1972 Topps 137 AFC Championship Game Miami Dolphins, Baltimore Colts nm-mt 15.00
1972 Topps 278 Bubba Smith All-Pro PSA 8 55.00
Bubba Smith Baltimore Colts Michigan State
1974 Topps 482 George Hunt Baltimore Colts Tennessee PSA 9 13.00rookie card
1975 Topps 456 1974 Highlights: Mitchell grabs 13 passes in game PSA 10 109.00
Lydell Mitchell Baltimore Colts Penn State
1976 Fleer Team Action 1 Baltimore Colts - High Scorers Baltimore Colts exmt 6.00
1976 Fleer Team Action 2 Baltimore Colts - Effective Tackle Baltimore Colts nm 10.00
1976 Fleer Team Action 61 Super Bowl V Baltimore Colts, Dallas Cowboys nm+ 15.00